La Roche-Posay Cicaplast vs Avène Cicalfate: Which barrier cream should you reach for?

Battle of the Barrier Creams: Cicaplast vs. Cicalfate

When your skin barrier is crying out for help — whether from dryness, irritation, or a recent dermatological treatment — two French pharmacy icons are likely on your radar: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Balm B5 and Avène Cicalfate+ Restorative Cream. Both promise to soothe, protect, and repair, but they achieve it in slightly different ways.

Ingredients and Formulation

Both formulas share comforting staples such as glycerin for hydration and emollients that help seal in moisture. Yet their repair strategies diverge. Cicaplast relies on panthenol (vitamin B5), shea butter, and dimethicone to form a protective film that locks in moisture and calms irritation. Some versions also include madecassoside and zinc gluconate, adding anti-inflammatory benefits.
Cicalfate+, meanwhile, uses Avène’s C+ Restore™ postbiotic complex, copper-zinc sulfate blend, and Avène Thermal Spring Water. This combination aims to support the skin’s microbiome and accelerate recovery, especially on irritated or post-procedure skin.

Texture and Feel

Cicaplast Balm B5 has a rich, balm-like texture that feels thick and occlusive — ideal for cracked lips, rough hands, or dry patches that need overnight protection. Cicalfate+ is a cream with a smoother, lighter consistency. It absorbs faster, making it more comfortable for use on larger areas or even under makeup.

Best for Which Skin Problems

If your skin is extremely dry, flaky, or cracked, Cicaplast offers the heavy-duty barrier you need to heal and protect. It’s particularly good for winter dryness or skin that needs a strong moisture seal.
If your skin is red, sensitive, or healing, Cicalfate+ provides a more breathable repair, perfect after procedures or for calming irritation. Its postbiotic and mineral blend helps restore balance without suffocating the skin.

The Bottom Line

Both products are fragrance-free and formulated for sensitive skin, but they serve slightly different purposes. Choose La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Balm B5 when you need intense nourishment and protection, and Avène Cicalfate+ when you need soothing recovery and microbiome support.
In short, Cicaplast protects, while Cicalfate repairs — two different paths to a healthier, calmer skin barrier.

This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I truly love and trust. Thank you for supporting my content!